The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a petition challenging the Uttar Pradesh government’s decision to deny the appointment of Vishal Saraswat as deputy collector in the Provincial Civil Services (Executive).
Saraswat, currently serving in the Indian Defence Estates Service as chief executive officer of the Roorkee Cantonment Board, had successfully cleared the Combined State & Upper Subordinate Service Examination, 2019.
The Court upheld the state government’s discretion to assess the suitability of candidates for sensitive roles, emphasizing the higher standard of scrutiny required for the position of deputy collector.
The High Court supported the state government’s stand, stating that public employers are not obligated to align their decisions with those of other employers in similar cases.