A reader wrote to Alison Green’s Ask a Manager column seeking advice on what to do with the boss’ son who is being overpaid and lacks qualifications for his job.
Jasper was hired to a senior role by the ex-CEO, his parent, who retired six months ago. In that time the new CEO has implemented new processes, including feedback for employees, but Jasper is still failing to perform.
The bigger issue is that he is being paid disproportionately for his job. Based on a comprehensive wage review for the industry, Jasper is being paid 10-15% more than is appropriate for his position. Other employees are being paid 20% less than their market value.
It’s not exactly his fault that the ex-CEO/parent put him in this situation, but do you keep paying him more than he’s worth?
It appears that Jasper is being treated as a special case, but this has hindered his performance, his professional network and given him unnecessary scrutiny.
Realistically, do you think Jasper will be able to perform at the level his job requires within a reasonable amount of time? If not, it might be best to let him go.
If Jasper will be able to perform at the required level then he should be given some notice that his pay will be cut but also given time to think.
It is best to deal with Jasper’s case candidly and head-on so that the situation can be cleaned up as quickly as possible.
The CEO could alternatively dismiss Jasper and pay him severance, explaining that he needs a different set of skills for the job. This may be the most straightforward option.