CarExpert received feedback on their review ratings through a Reddit thread indicating a narrow clustering of scores between 7.8 and 8.4.
Acknowledging the issue, CarExpert decided to revamp their rating system to enhance usefulness in car buying decisions.
The new rating system eliminates numerical references and uses descriptive words like excellent, very good, good, average, or below average.
A data-driven component of the new system compares ratings using objective data to position cars among their segment peers visually.
The data-driven ratings aim to showcase where a car stands in terms of fuel efficiency, helping readers make informed decisions.
While the new system isn't perfect due to varying car characteristics and reliance on manufacturer-supplied data, it aims to provide a more comprehensive evaluation.
Existing numerical ratings will be converted to word ratings, with ongoing improvements and feedback sought for refinement.
CarExpert appreciates reader input and commits to evolving the new rating system over time for increased accuracy and usefulness.
Readers are encouraged to provide constructive feedback for ongoing enhancements and understand that the iterative process will take time to mature.
The intention behind these changes is to offer a more user-friendly and transparent rating system that better serves the needs of prospective car buyers.