Probability problems like the Desk Swap Dilemma are considered as a perfect arena to test abstract thinking, ability to break down complex challenges into procedural steps, and discipline to avoid intuitive yet incorrect solutions.
A derangement is a permutation of a set of elements in which no element appears in its original position.
The Desk Swap Dilemma is a problem related to derangement mathematics that involves people swapping positions with one another in such a way that no one ends up in their original position.
The probability of at least one person ending up at their own desk in the Desk Swap Dilemma was found to be around 63% using Probability theory and the inclusion-exclusion principle.
Rather than solving the probability of at least one person ending up at their own desk directly, it is easier to compute the complement of P(X=0) using Probability Theory.
The inclusion-exclusion principle tells us how to calculate probabilities for unions of events in terms of intersections of events.
A more detailed but rigorous approach is needed to find the exact expression for a finite N. However, the limit of large N is more manageable and gives a simpler solution.
In the desk swap dilemma, given random desk allocations, each employee has an equal probability of P(Ak)=1/N of ending up at their original desk.
The event where employee k ends up at their original desk depends on the previous assignments.
The final result for the probability of at least one person ending up at their original desk is given by 1/e where e is Euler’s number.