Waymo's robotaxis and Tesla's FSD are put to the test in San Francisco by Business Insider's Lloyd Lee and Alistair Barr.
Waymo has been providing autonomous rides since 2024, while Tesla is gearing up to launch its robotaxi service in Austin.
The test involved Waymo's fifth-generation Waymo Driver in Jaguar I-PACE SUVs and Barr's 2024 Tesla Model 3 equipped with Hardware 4 and FSD Supervised software.
While both AI drivers showed impressive skills, Tesla's FSD made a critical error by running a red light, giving Waymo the clear win in the test.
Waymo displayed a safe yet assertive driving style, with small human-like moments, while Tesla's FSD handled highway driving flawlessly but made mistakes like running the red light.
The error by Tesla was significant as it would be considered an automatic fail during a driver's license test, prompting the testers to give Waymo the win.
Tesla's FSD still requires a human driver behind the wheel, while Waymo's fully autonomous rides have been operational in San Francisco.
Both services have their strengths, with Tesla's ability to handle certain routes and Waymo's attention to safety and efficiency.
Despite the error, Tesla aims to launch its robotaxi service soon, banking on its strong real-world data collection to make FSD smarter for fully autonomous operation.
The competition between Tesla's FSD and Waymo's robotaxis continues as both companies strive for a seamless autonomous ride-hailing experience.