A Tesla superfan, YouTuber Robert Rosenfeld, test drove a loaner 2025 Rivian R1S for a week but decided to keep his Tesla in the end.
The Rivian R1S Tri-Motor Max Pack, costing about $111,000, offers 371 miles of range, surpassing some Tesla models in range.
Rosenfeld appreciated the customization and options of Rivian's R1S, highlighting its trim levels, colors, and wheels compared to Tesla's configurability.
Despite liking the premium interior and driving experience of Rivian, Rosenfeld's loyalty to Tesla is due to software, especially the Full Self-Driving feature.
Rosenfeld compared the Tesla vs. Rivian experience to Apple vs. Android, with Tesla offering a more predefined experience and Rivian providing more options.
Rosenfeld's preference for Tesla also stemmed from its software, particularly its maps and HVAC controls, in comparison to Rivian's system.
While Rosenfeld admired Rivian's driving dynamics and top-down camera system, he appreciated Tesla's software features more, like Full Self-Driving.
YouTuber Darren Byrd, a pilot, shared a similar comparison after trading his Model X for an R1S, highlighting the R1S as a 'more normal car that happens to be electric.'
For those considering moving on from Tesla, options like the Hyundai Ioniq 5, Rivian, Polestar 3, and Porsche Taycan offer varying features worth considering.
Electric vehicle owners exploring alternatives to Tesla are encouraged to assess their priorities, whether it be range, software, or performance, before making a switch.