Apple is facing potential criminal contempt proceedings after federal judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found the company in willful violation of a 2021 injunction related to the Epic Games court case.
Judge Rogers accused Apple of thwarting the injunction's goals to maintain its revenue stream and called out Apple VP of Finance Alex Roman for lying to the court.
Tim Cook's actions were also criticized, with the judge stating that Apple chose the most anticompetitive options despite knowing their obligations.
The judge highlighted Apple's introduction of policies collecting a 27 percent commission, close to the previous 30 percent from in-app purchases, violating the injunction.
Judge Rogers referred the matter to state attorneys to consider pursuing criminal contempt against both Roman and Apple, emphasizing that willful disregard of court orders will not be tolerated.
Apple, while disagreeing with the decision, stated it would comply with the court order and intends to appeal.
Epic Games welcomed the ruling, with CEO Tim Sweeney seeing it as a victory for developers to offer their payment services alongside Apple's.
The ruling stems from the 2020 lawsuit where Epic Games aimed to allow third-party payment systems and app stores on Apple devices, leading to the 2021 injunction mandating changes to the App Store.
The judge previously found Apple in violation of California's unfair competition law for limiting developers from directing users to payment methods bypassing Apple's system.
The ruling marks a significant rebuke of Apple's practices and behavior, with Epic Games securing concessions to promote competition and alternative payment systems.
Overall, the legal battle between Apple and Epic Games underscores the increasing scrutiny on tech giants' dominance and anticompetitive practices in the digital market.