Recent observations by the James Webb Space Telescope suggest that Trappist-1 b could be either an airless rock or shrouded in a hazy CO2 atmosphere.The research provides thermal emission measurements for Trappist-1 b, presenting contradictory scenarios that challenge atmospheric models.One scenario suggests Trappist-1 b is an airless rocky planet with a young ultramafic surface due to strong tidal interactions and volcanic activity.Alternatively, the exoplanet could have a haze-rich CO2 atmosphere with a thermal inversion, as observed at 15µm.The presence of photochemical haze on Trappist-1 b is proposed to be due to hydrogen sulphide from volcanic activity, influenced by space weathering.The contradictory models pose an enigma about Trappist-1 b's true nature, which requires additional measurements for clarification.Further observations with broader spectral coverage and higher resolution spectroscopy are recommended to resolve the planetary paradox.JWST's findings emphasize the need for more data to distinguish between an airless surface and a CO2-rich atmosphere on Trappist-1 b.Co-author Gillon underscores the significance of acquiring additional data to differentiate between the two proposed models.TRAPPIST-1 b remains a mystery, with potential scenarios of being either a barren rock world or enveloped in a dense CO2 atmosphere.